report

Poland Spotlight

How to Approach Poland

The process of credit assessment has traditionally been built on a solid foundation of financial account analysis. A credit professional would scrutinize balance sheets, income statements, and cash flow statements of companies to gauge their financial health and determine their creditworthiness; such assessments delving into profitability ratios, liquidity ratios, efficiency ratios, and solvency ratios to get a comprehensive view of a company's ability to meet its financial obligations. This assessment is crucial as it provides a snapshot of a company's financial standing, its resources, and its ability to continue operations without defaulting on its commitments.

In a stable economic environment, these financial statements can provide a relatively reliable insight into a company's operational and financial status. However, in volatile markets or during periods of economic downturn, the reliance solely on such historical data can be somewhat misleading. Furthermore, these financial statements, as reliable as they may be, are often lagging indicators of a company's financial health. They provide an image of the company's past performance, which may not be an accurate representation of their current or future potential, especially if there have been significant changes in the market or the company's operations.

Specifically, in the context of Poland, where the majority of businesses operate as sole proprietorships, the problem is exacerbated. These entities are not obliged to publish full accounts, leading to a scarcity of information for credit assessment. Therefore, relying solely on the traditional methods of financial accounts assessment can prove insufficient and ineffective in these cases. The rapidly changing market conditions, along with the specific challenges posed by the Polish market structure, necessitate a re-evaluation of the credit assessment strategies. It underscores the need for credit professionals to adapt and include other performance indicators in their credit assessment toolkit.

Challenges in Poland

The unique business structure in Poland presents a distinct set of challenges for credit professionals, primarily because a large portion of businesses operate as sole proprietorships. These entities, unlike corporations, aren't legally obliged to publish full financial accounts, including balance sheets, income statements, or cash flow statements. As a result, credit professionals often face a significant obstacle in assessing the financial health and creditworthiness of these businesses, an issue known as information asymmetry.

Information asymmetry, in this case, refers to the imbalance where a business seeking credit has more information about its financial health and prospects than the credit professional attempting to assess its creditworthiness. This lack of financial transparency makes it difficult to accurately evaluate a company's ability to meet its financial obligations, potentially leading to inaccurate credit assessments. Consequently, such opacity can foster an environment conducive to higher credit risk, as credit professionals find it challenging to make well-informed credit decisions.

The lack of full accounts from sole proprietorships in Poland compounds the difficulties arising from a strategy reliant primarily on historical financial data. The limited financial information that is available is often being outdated or not adequately representing the company's current financial state or future potential.

Therefore, in the context of Poland, the traditional method of credit assessment based on financial account analysis becomes notably insufficient. The resultant information asymmetry and assessment difficulties necessitate the incorporation of additional parameters into the credit assessment process.

New Directions in Credit Assessment

Considering the limitations of relying on financial accounts for credit assessments, there's an emerging need to look beyond these traditional metrics. One such metric that can provide more accurate and timely insights into a company's financial health is its payment performance.

Payment performance is essentially a measure of a company's ability to meet its debt obligations on time. A strong payment performance indicates a business is financially stable and can consistently meet its commitments, reflecting positively on its creditworthiness. Conversely, a downturn in payment performance, characterised by late payments or default, can be a red flag indicating financial distress.

In Poland, where information asymmetry is a challenge, payment performance becomes even more useful. This metric can serve as a useful tool for credit professionals to gauge the financial health of businesses in real-time.

Monitoring payment performance allows for timely identification of potential financial troubles that might not yet be reflected in a company's financial accounts. In contrast to financial statements, which are often lagging indicators of a company's financial health, payment performance can offer more immediate insights.

Therefore, in the light of the unique challenges posed by the Polish market, credit professionals should consider pivoting from traditional credit assessment strategies and place more emphasis on tracking payment performance. This shift in focus will enable them to identify signs of financial distress promptly, allowing for quicker response and potentially reducing credit risk.

An increased focus on the Polish market involves the development and use of more nuanced and region-specific risk assessment tools and methodologies. These might also include industry-specific risk scoring models, local market trend analyses, and regularly updated databases of company payment records. As these tools often require specialist knowledge and skills, there's a clear need for increased investment in specialist expertise.

It's important to note that a shift in focus to payment performance doesn't imply an abandonment of traditional credit assessment tools, however. Instead, it suggests an expansion of the credit assessment toolkit with greater emphasis on real-time indicators of creditworthiness. In the Polish market, these real-time indicators can provide invaluable insights that help offset the information asymmetry issues inherent with prevalence of sole proprietorships.

Addressing Deteriorating Performance

Identifying red flags in the financial performance of customers is crucial in any market, and the Polish market is no exception. However, the uniqueness of this market structure brings its own set of challenges and specific indicators that credit professionals should be aware of.

A key sign of potential financial difficulties is consistent delay in payments. In Poland, this can be particularly challenging to navigate, as late payments could simply be symptomatic of the wider market norms or, could be serious indication of cash flow issues. Understanding the difference is critical. In Poland, there's a prevailing culture of late payments, often justified as a cash flow management technique. This trend is primarily due to the long payment terms common in various industries, which often extend beyond 30 days and, in some cases, reach up to 60 or 90 days. Businesses may often delay payments to the last possible moment as a way to maintain cash on hand.

However, frequent delays beyond these norms, especially if they reach past 90 days, can be a red flag for financial difficulties. A significantly high rate of delayed payments, paired with other concerning behaviours such as sudden requests for credit term extensions or repeated disputes over invoices, should be treated as potential signs of distress.

The challenge for businesses operating in Poland, then, is to differentiate between late payments as a common market practice and late payments as an indicator of deteriorating financial health. Consequently, it is crucial to have a firm understanding of industry-specific norms and to keep a close eye on any deviations from these norms that could indicate financial distress.

Requests for flexibility are a warning sign. Given the relative flexibility that Polish sole proprietorships have in managing their financial affairs, such requests may signify deeper issues. If a Polish company seeks extended payment terms or a conversion of short-term obligations into long-term ones, credit professionals should be alert to potential risks.

Similarly, customers suddenly seeking payment plans may also indicate financial instability. This is particularly relevant in Poland, where changes to tax legislation or other fiscal policies can disproportionately affect sole proprietorships' liquidity. Sole proprietorships in Poland, as in other parts of the world, are often smaller businesses managed by a single individual or family. This structure means they might lack the financial buffers of larger corporations and are thus more susceptible to changes in financial conditions, whether from changes in market dynamics or fiscal policy. If the government increases taxes or alters tax regulations, sole proprietorships may see a significant portion of their earnings redirected towards these increased tax obligations, thereby reducing their available cash for operations. Moreover, sole proprietorships might not have access to the same level of financial advice and tax planning resources as larger corporations. This factor could make it more challenging for them to anticipate and strategically plan for these changes, thus amplifying the impact on their liquidity.

Given these considerations, any sudden requests from sole proprietorships for payment plans or other changes in their usual payment behaviour should be closely evaluated for potential underlying financial instability.

Changes in buying patterns can also serve as red flags. A sudden increase or decrease in orders might be a reaction to market fluctuations, or it could signal strategic shifts and cash flow issues.

Finally, an increasing reliance on trade credit, including frequently maxing out credit lines or consistently opening and closing credit accounts, may indicate financial distress. The lack of financial transparency with Polish sole proprietorships amplifies the significance of this red flag.

These indicators necessitate proactive monitoring and early intervention. By identifying and addressing these red flags, credit professionals can assess the situation, initiate dialogue, and if necessary, make strategic decisions to protect their interests while supporting their customers.

Active dialogue between credit departments and their customers is vitally important. By initiating conversation early, credit professionals can better understand the reasons behind any changes in payment behaviour and assess their legitimacy, helping to mitigate potential risks.

It is particularly relevant in the context of Poland's business market, where understanding the unique circumstances and challenges of each customer is crucial. Direct communication can become an essential tool for accessing insights into their financial health. Moreover, the dialogue can shed light on context behind requests for flexibility or extended terms. Such requests, for instance, may stem from seasonal cash flow variations, changes in the local market, tax policy adjustments, or deeper financial issues. Understanding this context can help credit professionals distinguish between temporary cash flow issues and systemic financial instability.

Proactive communication allows credit departments to gauge the viability of a business. By engaging in discussions around their customers' future plans, market predictions, and overall business sentiment, credit professionals can get a better sense of the sustainability of their business models and financial stability. Such dialogue also helps foster stronger business relationships. This is especially important in the Polish market, where business culture values relationship-building. Regular communication not only builds trust, but it also signals to customers that credit departments are willing to support them through challenges while also ensuring their own interests are protected.

Establishing Supportive Agreements

Credit professionals face a delicate balance in supporting Polish businesses that are encountering temporary difficulties. Striking the right balance to maintain customer relationships and help these businesses navigate challenging times whilst also safeguarding the business’s own interests.

One approach involves restructuring the repayment plans, offering more flexibility without compromising one’s interests. This may include extended payment terms or instalment plans that consider the debtor's cash flow situation. Here, a third-party receivables management service could be invaluable. We help mediate between credit departments and customers, working out a mutually beneficial arrangement that both maintains customer relationships and ensures payment.

Another strategy is related to inventory and supply management. Credit professionals may negotiate consignment arrangements where the business does not pay for goods until they are sold. This approach can assist businesses with limited capital to continue operations, while credit departments retain some control over their inventory.

Credit insurance is another tool that can be especially useful in Poland's business context. It protects the credit department from the risk of non-payment, offering more security when providing support to businesses facing temporary difficulties.

Lastly, one may consider collaborating with local financial institutions and leveraging government support schemes designed to aid businesses in temporary distress. For instance, state-backed loan guarantee schemes have been established in Poland to support small and medium enterprises (SMEs) during tough economic times.

Astute management of these risks, a contextual understanding of the Polish market, and the utilisation of financial tools, including the services of a third-party receivables management, can enable credit professionals to provide support while safeguarding their interests. By doing so, we not only contribute to the survival and recovery of businesses but also foster stronger, more resilient business relationships in the long term.

Conclusion

In a complex credit environment like Poland, where sole proprietorships with limited financial transparency are predominant, a specially crafted strategy is vital for all market participants, not just those directly dealing with such businesses. Traditional credit assessment methods may be insufficient in this setting, given the market's inherent opacity. The prevalent business structure indirectly shapes the market’s dynamics, creating ripple effects that can impact all players, even those not directly dealing with these proprietorships. Thus, for any entity within this market, flexibility, anticipation, and strategic adaptation are less luxuries and more necessities for survival, and this holds true irrespective of whether their operations involve direct interactions with sole proprietorships.

Embracing real-time monitoring, fostering open dialogue with clients, and capitalizing on innovative tools such as third-party receivables management services become essential. But beyond risk mitigation and interest protection, these strategies offer an opportunity to redefine the role of credit departments in the business ecosystem.

In actively deciphering the idiosyncrasies of the Polish market, credit departments not only secure their own interests but also contribute to the stability and growth of the businesses they serve. This proactive, participatory approach allows them to transform potential challenges into avenues for collaborative growth, crafting a resilient and prosperous narrative within Poland's vibrant economic tapestry.

P.S.

Don't let market complexity hinder your decision-making process. Stay ahead with our latest resource, the "Poland Spotlight 2023" report. Authored by Chris Snelson, CFO at Baker Ing, this in-depth analysis explores unique economic aspects of Poland's market, including key economic areas for focus such as supply chain & demand problems, inflation, the Russia-Ukraine situation, government stability, currency trends, payment behaviours, and insolvency rates.

This strategic forecast is a must-have for every credit professional looking to navigate the intricate Polish market successfully. It not only provides a detailed market history and future forecasts but also translates high-level economic analysis into actionable insights for credit professionals.

Expand your credit assessment toolkit, mitigate risk and drive success with the comprehensive "Poland Spotlight 2023". Visit Global Outlook to download your copy now, and be equipped with invaluable insights into one of Europe's most dynamic markets.

by COL